Projectors: a price rise costs about as much rank as a cut gains
WHAT TO DO
Between €81 and €160, run a deal only with daily rank checks. A cut there showed no clear gain.
I measured 910 price changes across 182 projectors from €40 to €400 and compared each one against the products that held their price. A 10 percent cut improved the sales rank by about 9 percent within two weeks, and a 10 percent increase cost about 10 percent. Between €81 and €160 a cut showed no clear effect. This is report 12 of twelve in this quarter's consumer electronics series.
In short
- A cut moves the rank about one for one. A 10 percent cut improved the rank by about 9 percent (range 6 to 12) within two weeks.
- A rise costs about as much. A 10 percent increase cost about 10 percent of rank (range 7 to 13). I cannot separate the two directions.
- Between €81 and €160, a cut showed no clear gain. In the middle group the range for cuts includes zero, so I cannot say a cut helped there.
- Every rise cost rank. Rises in all three price groups cost rank, from about 6 percent per 10 percent below €81 to about 12 percent above €162.
- Newcomers flood this shelf. 233 new projectors arrived in two years on a shelf of 352, and 28 reached the top third.
Price cuts
A 10% cut improved rank by roughly 6 to 12 percent.
Price increases
A 10% increase cost roughly 7 to 13 percent of rank.
In the middle, a cut shows no clear gain
Budget projectors below €81 gained about 11 percent of rank per 10 percent cut, premium ones above €162 about 9. In the middle, the range for cuts runs from -0.06 to 1.21 and includes zero. There I cannot say a cut did anything.
Rises cost rank in every group. The ranges overlap, so I cannot rank the groups by how much a rise hurt.
At category level, cuts and rises moved the rank about as far as the price, and their ranges overlap.
The full picture
01 · Does discount depth matter?
Somewhat. Bigger moves did more, the steps blur into each other.
Every move counts, the steps blur
A cut of 5 to 15 percent improved the rank by 14 percent, 15 to 25 percent by 15 percent and more than 25 percent by 31 percent. Neighbouring steps overlap.
A rise of 5 to 15 percent cost 19 percent, 15 to 25 percent 42 percent and more than 25 percent 24 percent. These overlap too. Every step stays away from the no-change line.
02 · Will competitors follow?
No more than on any other day.
A cut changes nothing in how often others move
I looked at 1,289 cuts on 211 products. Within 14 days, some competitor changed a price after 96 percent of them. After a cut, competitors moved about 8 percent less often than in a normal two-week window.
After an increase it was about 3 percent less often. 68 percent of first moves fell on the same day as the trigger, which I cannot read as a reaction.
03 · Where can a new product get in?
Nowhere I can show on solid evidence.
Many newcomers, no band where they clearly win
category baseline (one third)
No corridor: no price band in this category met the entry criteria, so none is marked recommended.
In the last 24 months, 233 new products entered this category. 28 of them now rank in the top third, and 14 have left again.
The scoring in my tool points to €229 to €275. I overrule it, because only one newcomer there could be judged. Elsewhere newcomers reached the top third in several bands, but never more than three in any one band.
04 · What does the market look like?
A long shelf from €43 to €399, with many newcomers.
Of the 352 products I could place on the price map, 69 sit in the three cheapest bands, up to €75.04. 54 sit in the four most expensive bands, from €190.
The typical product in a band has between 53 and 320 reviews. A typical price held for 26 to 183 days, depending on the band.
Data appendix
I started from a list of 1,827 listings on amazon.de. I removed 273 listings that were not home projectors, such as hologram fans, star and logo projectors, toy projectors, screens and mounts. I also removed 1 multipacks and sets, 421 listings outside €40 to €400 and 260 listings with fewer than 20 reviews. To keep single brands from dominating, I kept at most three products per brand, which removed 479. Of the remaining 393 listings, 131 were variation groups that cannot be bought themselves. I replaced each with one sellable variant, the one with the longest price history, and checked the variants against the same rules. That gave 363 products. The upper limit of €400 leaves out most business and laser projectors, so this report covers the consumer end of the market. After the price history came in, I removed 9 whose typical price fell outside €40 to €400, which left 354. Of these, 129 never showed a price on amazon.de, so they add nothing to the figures.
I compare each product only against products in the same Amazon category, here "Beamer". That is stricter than title keywords, because a star projector for children's rooms calls itself a projector in its title too. 2 products sat outside this category, and none of their price changes reached the figures. The product list is available on request for methodological review.
| Step | Events | Removed because |
|---|---|---|
| Price changes found | 2,276 | n/a |
| Gaps in the price history | −156 | the price history had holes around the change |
| Too little ranking data | −144 | the rank was missing on too many days |
| Overlapping price change | −503 | another price change fell inside the measuring window |
| Deal or coupon markers | 0 | a deal or coupon ran at the same time |
| Stockout signals | −274 | the product looked out of stock |
| Burst of new reviews | −473 | reviews jumped at the same time |
| Listing too young | −185 | the listing was less than 60 days old |
| Too few control products | −152 | fewer than 5 comparable products held their price |
| Passed every check | 1,029 | one event can fail several checks |
| Used for the figures | 910 | minus 119 with a trend already running before the change |
price change ≥ 5% and ≥ €0.30, held ≥ 7 days · comparison: 14 days before, days 3 to 14 after · control products: same category, price moved less than 2%, at least 5 of them · rank coverage ≥ 70% of days · listing older than 60 days · review burst = more than 10% and at least 15 new reviews · ranges are 90%, from a bootstrap clustered by product · study protocol v1.1
The price changes I found range from −65 percent to +120 percent. Moves that large are rare. They do not drive the figures, which come from the dense middle. 74 percent of the used changes were cuts or increases of up to 25 percent.
Limits
- LIMITS. I measure the sales rank on Amazon. I cannot see units sold, and I look only at the two weeks after a change. Every figure holds only for the price moves sellers actually made in this category. The price groups are thirds of this set, so "premium" means €161.6 to €399 here. Competitor reactions are counted as any price change by another product in the category, which says nothing about intent. The entry view looks back 24 months and judges newcomers only once they have been listed long enough.
- 354 products
- 2,276 price changes found
- 1,029 passed every check
- 910 used for the figures
- 182 products in the fit set
- ref a74cfdc9
The Quarterly by email.
I send one email per edition, four times a year. It holds the full report and nothing else.